Baked Beans Recipe on Food52 (2024)

Simmer

by: Merrill Stubbs

May7,2021

4

8 Ratings

  • Prep time 10 minutes
  • Cook time 3 hours
  • Serves 4 to 6

Jump to Recipe

Author Notes

Baked beans may come out of a can more commonly than out of a pan, but we guarantee that a great homemade baked bean recipe will win over a tin every time. Whether you’re creating a classic line-up of sides for a “play the hits” barbecue, crafting a hearty game day feast for a crowd, or serving them as part of a loaded full English breakfast, baked beans in all their glorious forms are always welcome at the table.

Thick, sweet, and savory, these beans are delicious no matter which variety you use—and you can use most types of beans. Pick your favorite, or use two kinds of beans to mix it up, and give them a full 24 hours of soaking to ensure they’ll fully tenderize during cooking (though this recipe is also a surefire way to make canned beans better if you’re in a hurry).

I like to use bacon drippings as the fat owing to the famous flavor pairing of smoky pork and beans, but these baked beans can easily be made vegetarian by using butter, or vegan using your preferred cooking oil (or porkier by adding your smoked pork of choice). If you think the flavor of your beans would benefit from a dash of Worcestershire sauce, drizzle of molasses, or even a splash of tangy barbecue sauce—go for it! I add a little chipotle powder for added smokiness and a hint of heat that pairs especially well with grilled proteins and vegetables.
Merrill Stubbs

  • Test Kitchen-Approved

What You'll Need

Watch This Recipe

BakedBeans

Ingredients
  • 1/2 poundcranberry, pinto or cannellini beans, soaked overnight
  • salt
  • 2 sprigsthyme
  • 1 clove garlic, smashed
  • 1 small onion, diced (keep the ends for the beans)
  • 1 tablespoonbacon fat, oil, or butter
  • 1/8 teaspoonsweet paprika
  • 1 pinchchipotle powder (optional)
  • 2 cupschopped canned tomatoes
  • 2 tablespoonsapple cider vinegar
  • 1 1/2 teaspoonsDijon mustard
  • 1/4 cuppacked light brown sugar
Directions
  1. Cover the beans by at least an inch with cold water. Add a few pinches of salt and the thyme, garlic, and onion ends, and simmer until tender, about an hour.
  2. When the beans are close to being done, heat the oven to 250°F. Using a heavy, shallow ovenproof pan, sauté the onion in the bacon fat over medium-low heat until soft, about 5 minutes. Stir in the spices and cook for another minute. Stir in the rest of the ingredients and simmer gently for 5 to 7 minutes, stirring occasionally, until the mixture thickens slightly.
  3. Stir the beans and 1/2 cup of their cooking liquid into the sauce in the pan. Cover the pan and put it in the oven for an hour to an hour and a half, until the beans are very soft and the sauce has thickened a bit.
  4. Uncover the pan and cook until the sauce is quite dry and the edges of the pan are slightly caramelized, another 20 to 30 minutes, and serve.

Tags:

  • Stew
  • American
  • Bean
  • Tomato
  • Thyme
  • Simmer
  • Summer
  • Fourth of July
  • Winter
  • Spring
  • Fall
  • On the Cheap

See what other Food52ers are saying.

  • Karen Brooks

  • maam

  • ChristyBean

  • Merrill Stubbs

Popular on Food52

15 Reviews

Karen B. November 2, 2022

Loved this recipe, as did my husband. Since our farmers' market is still open, I used fresh, instead of dried, cranberry beans. Didn't have to pre-soak and the bean cooking time was about 30 minutes. Used bacon fat, as recommended. Substituted smoked sweet paprika for the regular sweet paprika. Added a dash of Worcestershire and a glug of barbecue sauce. End result was absolutely yummy. I love the tomatoes in the mix, but I think next time I'll cut them back to 1-1/2 cups. Definitely will make again with dried beans when fresh are no longer available!

aclincol February 6, 2021

Made it as directed with a bit of jarred chipotle paste. And tomatoes from the freezer. It was easy and really delicious. The perfect amount of sweetness. Thanks!

Merrill S. February 9, 2021

So glad you enjoyed it, and great idea to add chipotle paste!

JJGood April 21, 2020

Would I regret adding some diced carrots along with the onions for a little extra veg?

Merrill S. February 9, 2021

Oh, JJ! I missed your question way back in April -- I'm so sorry! What did you end up doing?

JJGood February 9, 2021

I still haven’t made them, actually! I can’t remember why I didn’t at the time—but I don’t think it was for want of carrot advice :)

Merrill S. February 9, 2021

Ha! Well, for the record I think adding carrots wouldn't hurt!

food52fan July 9, 2019

Like others who have commented, I'm also wondering whether the recipe calls for 2 tomatoes, or 2 cans of tomatoes. If cans, what size? I'm leaning toward just 2 tomatoes but would like to be sure. This will be a side dish for a family bbq. Looks delicious!

Merrill S. July 9, 2019

Apologies, it should read "2 cups chopped canned tomatoes" -- fixing now!

food52fan July 9, 2019

Wow, that was fast! Thanks, Merrill! Your recipe is on my menu for my mom's 85th birthday party this weekend!

Merrill S. July 9, 2019

Happy birthday to your mom!!

food52fan July 9, 2019

Thank you! :-D

Rachel April 3, 2018

Delicious. This is a keeper and will go into regular rotation in my house. I was liberal with the spices because we like things on the hot side and used butter since that's what I had. I have a home office and this is perfect to make during my mid-afternoon "coffee break". I can leave it in the oven and have something that smells wonderful while cooking and is ready for dinner when I shut off my computer.

maam November 1, 2015

Very good.
I served them with BBQ dry rubbed pork loin chops. I was looking to find a recipe substitute for the high sodium canned beans...this is definitely it.
They have a nice subtle more sophisticated flavour. As per popular request though (my husband), I will make an extra batch of the sauce. I will cook it in the oven separately for him to use with the beans and pork chops. I feel if I doubled the sauce in the recipe it would ruin that nice caramelization that occurs stove top at the end of the cooking time. Some extra served in a nice ramekin on the side would then be a good solution for the both of us.

ChristyBean January 7, 2014

I made this last night, and the husband loved it. I think I got him off of Heinz's canned baked beans, ha! I wasn't sure about the tomatoes (2 15-oz cans of chopped tomatoes or two whole, canned tomatoes that have then been chopped??), and since I threw the pan in the oven before leaving for aquagym, I put in 2 cans for fear of the beans drying out. This version was very tomatoey and delicious with a fried egg on top with some bread on the side. I need to find more non-slow-cooker recipes that I can throw in the oven for 90 minutes and come home to a meal ready to go!

Baked Beans Recipe on Food52 (2024)

FAQs

What is the secret to soft baked beans? ›

If the beans are too dry, add some hot water—or leftover bean-cooking water, if you still have some—until they're just saucy enough.

What can I add to baked beans to make them taste better? ›

​Change it up!
  1. ​Add a variety of beans! Swap one of the cans of baked beans for a can of (drained) kidney beans or navy beans. ...
  2. Add peppers! Add some diced green pepper or red bell pepper for a little more color and flavor.
  3. Turn up the heat! Add a pinch of cayenne pepper and some crushed red pepper for a little kick!
Apr 25, 2023

Are baked beans good for your heart? ›

They also contain minerals such as iron and zinc, and are a good source of B vitamins such as folate. Including beans and pulses in your diet is also associated with a lower cardiovascular risk and may help balance blood sugar levels.

What can I add to my beans to make it soft? ›

These beans can often take much longer to soften while soaking and cooking, up to twice the time! Baking soda can help significantly since it increases the pH of the water, disintegrating that pectin and allowing beans to soften quicker.

How do you cook beans and make it soft quickly? ›

Soaking. Soaking your beans helps them cook faster and more evenly, and it can also make them easier to digest. If you add salt to the soaking water (in other words, make a brine), your beans will cook even faster; the salt helps break down their skins.

Why do my baked beans taste bland? ›

Overcooking your beans

Signs that your beans are overcooked include them being very soft and mushy. Tender beans are ideal, but if they lack firmness and don't keep their shape, they have probably simmered for too long. Overcooked beans will also start to lose their flavor, leaving a flat taste.

Why do my baked beans taste weird? ›

Smell: If the beans have a foul, sour, or rancid odor, it means that they have gone bad and should not be consumed. Taste: If the beans have an unusual or off flavor, or if they taste sour or bitter, it's likely that they have gone bad.

How do you enhance the flavor of canned baked beans? ›

A few ideas:
  1. Rinse the beans.
  2. Spice (cumin, paprika, chili powder, garlic powder, onion powder) and warm them up.
  3. Mix with other ingredients (add vegetables, cooked rice, pasta, or use them as a filling for wraps or tacos)
  4. Mix with your own sauce (onion+bell pepper+carrot+canned tomatoes)
Aug 3, 2023

Why put ketchup in baked beans? ›

Ketchup: I slather the top of the bacon with ketchup which caramelizes in the oven while the beans bake low and slow. It not only adds to the gorgeousness of the dish, but the flavor too.

What can I use in place of molasses in baked beans? ›

  • Honey. Generally speaking, honey is very sweet, floral in flavor, and golden in color. ...
  • Sorghum. Sorghum is sometimes known as sorghum molasses, which tells you how similar these syrups are. ...
  • Maple Syrup. ...
  • Dark Corn Syrup. ...
  • Golden Syrup. ...
  • Brown Sugar. ...
  • Simple Syrup. ...
  • Black Treacle.
Dec 5, 2019

What can I add to baked beans to prevent gas? ›

The one tried and true method she taught me to reduce the gassy effect of beans, is this: add a tiny amount of baking soda to the pot half an hour or so before you're ready to serve them to “release” the gasses from them. Be set to stir down the violent reaction. This works no matter how you've seasoned them.

Is it OK to eat a tin of baked beans everyday? ›

Yes! "Eating beans, including canned beans, every day is one of the best things you can do to help increase nutrients [that you may fall short on] and substantially improve the quality of your diet," says Papanikolaou.

Do baked beans affect blood pressure? ›

Pulses, beans, lentils, and peas have been shown to significantly lower blood pressure in people with high and without high blood pressure. Beans are packed with fiber and protein, which have been shown to naturally help reduce blood pressure.

Are Bush's baked beans healthy? ›

The Bottom Line. Baked beans are high in protein, fiber, other nutrients, and beneficial plant compounds. They may improve gut health and cholesterol levels.

Why do my baked beans come out hard? ›

Beans and barley require different cooking times, so it's a good idea to cook them separately, then combine them and adjust the seasoning. You don't say how long you cooked them for, but if they're still tough, they most likely weren't cooked long enough. The older beans are, the longer they take to become tender.

Does adding baking soda help soften beans? ›

The addition of baking soda to the cooking water does two things: It adds sodium ions that weaken the pectin as explained above, and more importantly, an alkaline environment causes the pectin molecules to break down into smaller molecules that greatly weakens the pectin causing the beans to soften much more rapidly.

What softens beans quickly? ›

Use the power of baking soda to get dried beans to soften up faster. Rinse and sort your beans. Place them in pot and cover with water, sprinkle on a tablespoon or so of baking soda and bring to a boil. Boil for 10 minutes.

How long to soak beans to make them soft? ›

Before cooking, all dried beans need to be rehydrated by soaking. The 10- to 12-hour overnight soak is the easy and always effective method, but you can quick-soak beans by bringing them to the boil for one minute, then covering the pan and letting them sit for one hour.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Catherine Tremblay

Last Updated:

Views: 6062

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (67 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Catherine Tremblay

Birthday: 1999-09-23

Address: Suite 461 73643 Sherril Loaf, Dickinsonland, AZ 47941-2379

Phone: +2678139151039

Job: International Administration Supervisor

Hobby: Dowsing, Snowboarding, Rowing, Beekeeping, Calligraphy, Shooting, Air sports

Introduction: My name is Catherine Tremblay, I am a precious, perfect, tasty, enthusiastic, inexpensive, vast, kind person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.